Considerations for Health Care Professionals in the Education of PANS-Affected Students
Jamie Candelaria-Greene PhD, BCET
The Unique Symptomatology and Presentation of PANS in Students
Historically, PANS’ symptomatology represents a phenomenon that few educators in Special Education, much less Education, have ever seen before. Specifically, since the advent of Special Education programs in the 1960’s in the U.S. and abroad, the debilitations, needs, and behaviors of PANS-affected students emerge as distinct in three ways:
First, in the experience of most educators, the degree to which PANS-stricken students are affected by this disability is far less stable over time than what is usually seen with other students. For example, educators do not ordinarily expect a student’s printing ability to go from a third-grade level to a first-grade level in the span of a week, and then a month or two later, return back to a third-grade level.
Secondly, most students- even in Special Education- rarely suffer such significant debilitation in so many functional domains. Yet (and predictably), PANS-induced inflammation in the basal ganglia, along with cytokine-induced sickness behaviors, will result in the very symptoms cited in the diagnostic model of PANS itself: “anxiety, emotional lability and/or depression, irritability, aggression and/or severely oppositional behaviors, behavioral (developmental) regression, deterioration in school performance, sensory or motor abnormalities, and somatic signs and symptoms, including sleep disturbances, enuresis, or urinary frequency”. Alone and in combination, PANS thwarts the very elements needed to flourish in the learning environment: the ability to remember, sustain attention, organize, and plan; behave and communicate in age-appropriate ways, complete tasks that require expected fine and gross motor capabilities, etc.
Thirdly, PANS, once and forever, banishes the common pedagogical assumption that every student will generally progress on an ‘onward and upward path’- developmentally, intellectually, motorically, and socially. The calling card of PANS, in contrast to this generally sustained, steady, academic trajectory, results instead in jagged levels of dysfunction; but equally as striking, also improvement (and for many, full recovery) of functioning over time, once given appropriate medical treatment.
In sum, in its stunning depth and breadth of characteristics; erratic waxing and waning nature; and jagged descent and potential for full recovery, the presence of PANS in the classroom has broadened pedagogical assumptions and practices in the following ways: Educators now more readily acknowledge the phenomena of jagged levels of dysfunction and improvement across the functional domains (for both known and unknown reasons). Next, there is greater awareness that for some students, their actual knowledge of subject matter will not be equivalent to what they actually know, but rather, what they are able to demonstrate, given, as in the case of PANS, the constraints imposed by brain inflammation and ‘sickness behaviors.’ Moreover, there is greater acknowledgement that students’ medical illnesses are not just limited to physical symptoms only. Most significantly, the emergence of PANS in the schools has facilitated far greater awareness that behavioral/learning/emotional issues can have medical causes at their root. Accordingly, there is recognition that without the application of appropriate medical care, the efficacy of any other therapies (including educational services) may be limited, unlikely to help, and even be counterproductive.
Collaboration with the Schools
In ordinary times and in ideal academic settings, the collaboration between the health care provider and the school might look like this: First, the provider would speak candidly with the parent and the patient about issues that are seen to affect (or even might be affecting ) the patient’s education and wellbeing. The provider would then, with the agreement and collaboration of the parent and/or patient, communicate in writing to the patient’s school, college, or university. This document would usually include the diagnosis, and pertinent medical information surrounding the health of this patient (such as related diagnoses, status of treatment, medications, dietary restrictions, allergies, etc. ). It would also include any symptomatology that is known or suspected to affect the student’s ability to obtain an appropriate education.
This discussion might include questions such as, “Currently, how does this young person…?”
- Demonstrate age appropriate self-care and daily living skills surrounding grooming, transportation, nighttime routines, eating, etc.? (How long is it taking for the student to carry out grooming activities, such as bathing, dressing, and tooth brushing? Does the student experience upset, anxieties, or sensory overwhelm while traveling, etc.?)
- Adapt to transitions and stresses common in the educational, home, and other environments, including, or involving, decision-making, attendance, scheduling, and interactions with others?
- Follow, understand, and remember written, oral, and visual information (and combinations of the three)?
- Sleep and eat in ways that produce required levels of wakefulness and nutritional intake, respectively?
- Maintain prior levels of urinary frequency during the day and night? How do these levels compare with peers?
- Experience sensory overwhelm to light, sounds, textures, odors, etc.?
- Maintain social relationships. (In what ways has his or her social life changed or stayed the same?)
- Communicate effectively with others, and interact and behave in ways that are age-appropriate?
- Maintain prior levels of mental and physical stamina and coordination, (independently and in group activities)?
- Sustain focused attention (on non-stimulating, ‘non-fun’ tasks) for longer than 10 minutes?
- Complete chores and educational routines (i.e. homework) in a timely manner?
- How is this condition affecting the rest of family? Is the parent concerned over the child’s safety, or the safety of those around him? Is the parent concerned about how the patient’s behaviors are being interpreted at school?
- And, of course, acquire and demonstrate academic knowledge (indicating the degree to which s/he may need additional assistance, direction, and time to learn and to participate in an academic setting)?
The responses to the above questions will go far to document the types of limitations that will determine the scope of assessments, services, accommodations, adjustments, and modifications that the student may receive through educational institutions. Just as importantly, it will bring critical attention to everyone involved, that in this case, it is a medical condition, (and not a specific learning disability, poor student attitude, weak parenting skills, etc.) that is primarily responsible for current levels of academic performance, behavior, and attention. The provider may also specifically point out recommendations (based on symptomatology) that would be appropriate (or even inappropriate) for this student, such as a part time school day, home hospital instruction, in-class assistance from an aide, testing accommodations; and in college, separate living quarters, etc.
Based on communications brought forth by the medical provider, the school may then initiate assessments to further determine levels of needs and services. In some cases, a student’s testing abilities may be limited due to the constraints of the illness itself (such as thwarted energy levels, etc.). Moreover, many postsecondary settings are not required to offer testing, and, of course, during the current pandemic, assessments may not be feasible. In such circumstances, the provider’s letter may often suffice to make adjustments to the student’s educational plan, without additional evaluations.
Otherwise, the following assessments may be initiated:
- A school nursing plan, so that the district nurse can evaluate and monitor aspects of nursing needs related to PANS and the student’s education. The School Nurse would also collaborate with the family and other team members on assessments and services related to parameters of the student’s physical health and mental health diagnoses, status of energy, stamina, affect, and mood, and unintended/non-purposeful physical movements and utterances, such as tics.
- A psycho-educational evaluation, to determine present levels of processing strengths and weaknesses (such as in the areas of perceptual reasoning; processing speed; visual and auditory memory (separately, together, and sustained), etc.
- Evaluations in specific areas of visual processing, to include visual analysis, discrimination, analysis/synthesis, short term, long term, and working memory, visual-spatial orientation, and scanning.
- Evaluations to determine levels of functional behavior, social/emotional development, and executive functioning.
- Assessments to determine the need for psychiatric and counseling referrals (for both student and parent ), and to address any reported symptoms of anxiety, Obsessive Compulsive Disorder, emotional lability and/or depression, irritability, aggression and/or severely oppositional behaviors, and behavioral and developmental regression.
- Assessments to determine present levels of academic skills and achievement, such as in reading, math, and writing.
- Evaluations to evaluate fine motor weaknesses, (including handwriting difficulties), appropriate Assistive Technology applications, levels of skills of daily living (including grooming, dressing, and eating), and current levels of sensory integration, dysfunction, or overwhelm, and proprioception and vestibular issues.
- Evaluations to determine levels of gross motor ability, and the need for Adapted Physical Education to manage symptoms of poor coordination, hypoactivity, hyperactivity, and to facilitate the student’s participation in recess, on field trips, and in group sports.
- Evaluations by a Speech and Language Pathologist to determine (verbal and non-verbal) receptive and expressive language abilities, oral motor abilities, articulation, social pragmatics, non-purposeful vocalizations or tics., etc.
The results of these evaluations will signal appropriate services related to this student’s areas of need. These can include, but are not limited to, supports, assistance, and therapies in the areas of organization, attention, memory, fine motor and gross motor skills, visual processing, and result in services for speech and language, school nursing, counseling, and math, reading, and literacy supports. Moreover, ‘Home Hospital’ instruction may also be warranted, where an instructor comes to the home.
Accommodations/Adjustments/and Modifications are specific to the student’s needs, and can include a broad array of measures. A very few include: Testing accommodations (such as extended time on tests and testing in a distractive free environment), prioritization of assigned work to show competence, especially during PANS flares, Assistive Technology to accommodate for fine motor and processing speed weaknesses, a scribe, attendance modifications, a modified school day, the accompaniment of a service animal, and devices to assist with sensory overwhelm, etc. At the post-secondary level, accommodations might also include accommodations for Priority Registration for upcoming classes, extra time on ‘short turn around’ assignments, single dorm rooms, etc.).
It is also important that medical providers are aware of local, state or provincial, and national governmental policies that determine access to health services for their patients. In the U.S., for example, a ‘Free and Appropriate Public Education’ (FAPE) is mandated for every child; however, ‘free and appropriate public health care’ is not. This carries special significance for PANS-affected students, regarding not only the delivery of educational services, but also of ‘designated instructional services’ (such as speech therapy, counseling, etc.). By law, U.S. schools must provide an ‘appropriate’ education to every student, regardless of the severity or breadth of his needs. This holds true, whether the student is being appropriately medically treated for PANS, or whether the student is not (but still having associated symptoms being played out in the classroom). Schools must also provide supportive services and therapies, whether or not the family has the resources to provide them on their own. In their communications with the schools then, U.S. providers should be mindful of the weight that their communications hold in validating the need for these assessments and services, as they may be otherwise unobtainable elsewhere.
PANS, Education, and COVID-19
…However, these are not ordinary times. As we face special challenges surrounding the COVID-19 pandemic, here are a few highlights to consider:
Families and providers who have long dealt with the phenomena of PANS will recognize the devastating neuropsychiatric outcomes that can result from pathogens. Emerging information on the COVID-19 also suggests that like PANS, a delayed and powerful immune response can be involved and that like PANS, the individual, along with his ‘vector,’ may be totally asymptomatic of the pathogen that precipitates this onslaught. As a result, the school environment must be mindful of safety surrounding both PANS and COVID-19.
In collaboration with the parent, and the patient as appropriate, the provider may consider the following:
- Many of our students will continue to receive what is called Distance Learning (involving virtual teaching platforms, workbooks, phone calls, and other non in-person communications, to continue education during school closures. In the US, IDEA provides that Distance Learning may be an option for a student with a disabling condition or illness that warrants a physical absence from school.
- As certain types of assessments will be limited due to distancing precautions, the health provider’s role in identifying limitations associated with this student’s illness will be paramount. Such information will help facilitate or confirm the need and modes for educational services. He or she will also be an important point of contact regarding the documentation of worsening symptoms (that can warrant additional needs or services from the school, such as counseling, etc.). Moreover, the provider may cite the need for extended periods of Distance Learning for the student after the current COVID-19 crisis lightens up- even for siblings who may bring the illness home to the vulnerable student.
- The wearing of a face mask may be exempted for students who, because of their disability’s limitations (directly related to symptoms, age, or hearing/communication impairment, etc. ) may make them otherwise unable to wear a mask.
- ‘Compensatory education’ may be appropriate for students once they resume their education, to help them ‘catch-up’.
- Educational meetings in the US (such as IEP’s, Individualized Family Service Plans (IFSPs) Addendum meetings, Transition Plans, etc.) should continue according to stated timelines. However, they may be held virtually or by telephone, for example, when needed.
- With the parent, establish a main point of school contact during Distance-Learning and Shelter in Place periods.
- Identify public health guidelines that will directly affect services and modes of education, transportation, etc.
- In collaboration with the parent, your feedback on the efficacy of in-class learning, Hybrid Learning, and Distance Learning for your patient will be important. Safety, of course, is the number one priority. Even after the current pandemic crisis subsides, issues surrounding the needs of anyone vulnerable to infection may continue to warrant some levels of Distance Learning. At the same time, programs used in Distance Learning require adequate levels of executive functioning and sustained attention to be effective. As these are abilities our students often struggle with, there may need to be someone from the school to help facilitate this student’s progress in certain online programs (such as in math, etc.).
In Closing
While suffering through its worst manifestations, many PANS-stricken young people have little awareness of how dangerously close to peril they can become, especially during times of acute anxiety and debilitation. It will be those unsung health care providers who take these young sufferers’ hands, and lead them out of the chaos into refuges of safety. It is their letters, communications, and collaboration with families and schools, that will elucidate, and validate, that it is ultimately a medical condition that is responsible for this student’s altered learning ability and behavior. Their life-changing words and actions will forever alter the trajectories of these irreplaceable young people.
The above information is an excerpt from Considerations for Health Care Professionals in the Education of PANS-Affected Students. Access the entire article at HERE.
Dr. Candelaria-Greene is a researcher, educator, and clinician in Special Education in the San Francisco Bay Area. She has been a major collaborator with the ‘PANDAS Network Working Group on Educational Access’ since its inception. As a Visiting Researcher Scholar at UC Berkeley (2013-2015), she investigated the effects of PANS on learning and behavior. Her findings led to the book, “PANS, CANS, and Automobiles: A Comprehensive Reference Guide for Helping Students with PANDAS and PANS.” A second edition is forthcoming. Her website can be reached at: drcandelariagreene.com.